Establishment in an H&C application: the ten questions an officer asks about your life in Canada
Establishment is often the heart of an in-Canada H&C application. Here is what IRCC tells its officers to look at, how time in Canada is treated, and how to show it on paper.

A humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) application asks IRCC to grant permanent residence from inside Canada when you do not fit another class. There is no points grid. An officer weighs your whole situation, and for many people the heaviest part of that is establishment: the life you have built here.
This guide sets out what IRCC tells its own officers to look at, how your time in Canada is treated, and how to turn your life here into evidence.
Establishment is one factor, weighed with the others
IRCC lists the factors it may consider, including establishment in Canada, an inability to leave Canada that has led to establishment, ties to Canada, the best interests of any children affected, health, family violence, separation from relatives, and conditions in your country of origin.
No single factor decides the case. Following the Supreme Court of Canada in Kanthasamy v. Canada, 2015 SCC 61, IRCC tells officers they must consider and weigh all the relevant factors, and that individual factors should not be looked at in isolation. Since December 10, 2015 there has been no hardship “test” for these applications. Strong establishment can carry real weight, and weak establishment can be offset by other factors.
The ten questions officers consider
IRCC’s instructions on establishment list the points below. The right-hand column is our practical note on the kind of evidence that usually speaks to each one.
| What the officer considers | Evidence that usually shows it |
|---|---|
| How long you have been in Canada | Entry stamps, permits, a dated history of your addresses |
| Whether the reasons you stayed were beyond your control | Proof of pending applications, a removal suspension for your country, or other events you could not control |
| Whether you were covered by a deferral or suspension of removals | The applicable notice or decision |
| How far you co-operated, especially on travel documents | Passport applications, embassy correspondence |
| A history of stable employment | Employment letters, pay stubs, T4s, work permits |
| A pattern of sound financial management | Notices of assessment, bank statements, lease or mortgage, savings |
| Whether you stayed in one community or moved around | Lease history, school records for children, a long-standing doctor or place of worship |
| Integration through organizations, volunteering or other activities | Letters from organizations with dates and hours, not only character references |
| Professional, language or other studies | Transcripts, certificates, language test results |
| A good civil record for you and your family | Police certificates; an explanation of any charge |
How long is long enough?
There is no minimum. IRCC tells officers there is no strict rule on time in Canada, but that a significant degree of establishment is expected to take several years. Officers can consider establishment up to the time of the first-stage assessment, so keep adding evidence while your file waits.
IRCC is also clear that some establishment is not, by itself, enough. What matters is the degree of it, and what it would mean to uproot it.
Why you stayed matters as much as how long
IRCC says a positive decision may be warranted where you could not leave Canada for a significant time because of circumstances beyond your control, and you built significant establishment in that time.
| Treated as beyond your control | Treated as within your control |
|---|---|
| Your country was under a deferral or temporary suspension of removals | Refusing to sign or give information for a passport application |
| You spent several years in Canada with status waiting for a decision on an application | Wilfully losing or destroying travel documents |
| Other circumstances you genuinely could not control | Going “underground” and remaining in Canada illegally |
A suspension of removals does not guarantee anything either way. IRCC quotes the Federal Court (Saleh, 2024 FC 135): a moratorium on removals does not stop an H&C refusal, and does not mean the application will automatically be allowed.
Rules that sit around the establishment question
- It does not stop removal. IRCC says an H&C application will not delay removal; you must leave on the date set.
- The 12-month bar. You generally cannot apply within 12 months of a refugee claim being rejected or abandoned at the Refugee Protection Division or Refugee Appeal Division. Exceptions: children under 18 who would be directly and adversely affected by your removal, or a risk to life because your country cannot provide adequate medical care.
- One at a time. Only one H&C application can be under consideration at any time.
- Inconvenience is not enough. IRCC says the cost and inconvenience of returning home to apply for permanent residence are not sufficient factors on their own.
- Children have their own establishment. In the best interests of a child, IRCC looks at the child’s own establishment in Canada, along with age, schooling, health and conditions in the country of origin.
Making establishment visible
- Build a dated timeline of your years in Canada: status, addresses, jobs, studies.
- For every period, match a document. Gaps invite doubt, so explain them in writing.
- Show money as well as work: tax filings, savings, steady rent or mortgage payments.
- Ask organizations for letters that state dates, hours and your role, not only praise.
- If you lost status, explain why honestly and show what was beyond your control.
- Keep collecting evidence after you file. Establishment counts up to the first-stage review.
Read more on our H&C applications page, or our note on leaving Canada while an H&C is under review. Our Brampton and London offices prepare H&C submissions and can review your evidence. Book a consultation.
General information only, not legal advice. Sources: IRCC program delivery instructions, Establishment in Canada, Assessment and processing and Hardship and the H&C assessment; Guide 5291. Confirm current requirements on canada.ca. IRCC makes all final decisions.
Questions, answered
What does establishment mean in an H&C application?
It is how settled your life in Canada has become: your work history, how you manage money, how rooted you are in one community, your volunteering and studies, and your civil record. IRCC lists establishment in Canada as one of the factors it considers in a humanitarian and compassionate application.
How many years in Canada do I need for an H&C application?
There is no fixed number. IRCC tells its officers there is no strict rule on time in Canada, but that a significant degree of establishment is expected to take several years. Having some establishment is not, on its own, enough for approval.
Does time without status count against my establishment?
It depends on why you stayed. IRCC asks officers whether the reasons you remained were beyond your control, such as years spent waiting with status for a decision, or a suspension of removals to your country. Going underground, or refusing to help obtain a passport, is treated as within your control and can weigh against you.
Will an H&C application stop my removal from Canada?
No. IRCC says an H&C application does not delay removal. If you are under a removal order, you must leave on the removal date.
Can I apply for H&C soon after my refugee claim was refused?
Usually not for 12 months after a negative decision from the Refugee Protection Division or Refugee Appeal Division. The bar does not apply if you show credible evidence that children under 18 would be directly and adversely affected by your removal, or that your life would be at risk because your country cannot provide adequate medical care.

