The best interests of the child in an H&C application: what officers must weigh, and what you must show
When a child is affected by an H&C decision, the officer must assess that child's best interests. Which children count, the factors IRCC lists, how much weight they carry, and how to put them on the record.

Section 25(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act tells IRCC to take into account the best interests of a child directly affected when it decides a humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) application. It is often called BIOC. IRCC’s instructions to its officers say every H&C decision must include this assessment for any child directly affected.
This guide covers which children count, what officers are told to look at, how much weight it carries, and how to put a child’s situation on the record. For the other big factor, see our guide to establishment in Canada.
Which children count
| Question | What IRCC says |
|---|---|
| Does it have to be my child? | No. The relationship does not matter. The only requirement is that the child is directly affected by the decision |
| Does the child have to be in Canada? | No. It can be a Canadian or foreign-born child, and can include children outside Canada |
| How old? | Under 18 when IRCC receives the application. Older children may still be relevant to your case, but it is then not a best-interests assessment |
The factors officers look at
IRCC gives officers a list of examples. It says the list is not exhaustive and no single item decides the outcome:
- The age of the child
- How dependent the child is on the applicant
- The child’s establishment in Canada
- Who has legal custody
- The child’s links to the other country
- Conditions in that country and how they would affect the child
- Medical issues or special needs
- The impact on the child’s education
- Matters related to the child’s gender
- The child’s own point of view
IRCC also tells officers to consider the child’s emotional, social, cultural and physical welfare when these are raised, and to think about how different parts of a child’s identity combine. If the facts suggest a decision could put a child in danger, that has to be addressed too.
How much weight it carries
Two Supreme Court of Canada decisions frame this. In Baker (1999) the Court said decision-makers must be “alert, alive and sensitive” to the interests of children. In Kanthasamy (2015) it said it is not enough to state that a child’s interests were considered: they must be identified, defined and examined with real care. It also recognised that circumstances that would not justify relief for an adult can justify it for a child.
IRCC’s own instructions put the balance this way:
- Factors affecting children should be given substantial weight.
- The best interests of a child are one of many important factors, not a trump card. They do not automatically outweigh everything else.
- The officer must consider all the evidence you submit, then weigh everything together.
The burden is on you
IRCC says the onus is on the applicant, and that it must be clear from your material that you rely on the best interests of a child. An officer is not required to build that case for you. If the evidence is thin, the officer may decide the child’s interests were not shown and refuse relief. Where an applicant struggles to explain things in writing, IRCC says an interview may be warranted, but you should not plan on one.
Evidence that speaks to each factor
| Factor | Evidence that usually shows it |
|---|---|
| Dependency and custody | Birth certificates, custody orders, proof of who cares for and supports the child day to day |
| Establishment in Canada | School enrolment and report cards, activities, friendships, community letters |
| Education | Letters from teachers or the school on progress, language of instruction, special programs |
| Health and special needs | Medical reports, treatment plans, evidence of what care is available in the other country |
| Country conditions and gender | Recent, objective reports on conditions the child would actually face |
| The child’s point of view | A letter from the child where age-appropriate, or a professional assessment |
Write about each child separately. Explain what would happen in each realistic scenario, for example if the parent is removed and the child stays, or if the whole family leaves, and back every statement with a document.
Where children change the rules
- The 12-month bar. You normally cannot apply within 12 months of a refused or abandoned refugee claim. The bar does not apply if you show credible evidence that children under 18 would be directly and adversely affected by your removal.
- It still does not stop removal. IRCC says an H&C application does not delay a removal order, even when children are involved.
Read more on our H&C applications page. Our Brampton and London offices prepare H&C submissions and can review the evidence for each child. Book a consultation.
General information only, not legal advice. Sources: IRCC program delivery instructions, Best interests of a child (BIOC) and Assessment and processing; Guide 5291; Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, section 25. Confirm current requirements on canada.ca. IRCC makes all final decisions.
Questions, answered
Which children count in a best interests of the child assessment?
Any child directly affected by the decision. IRCC says this can be a Canadian or foreign-born child, can include children outside Canada, and does not depend on the relationship with the applicant. The child must be under 18 when IRCC receives the application.
Does the best interests of a child guarantee approval of an H&C application?
No. IRCC tells officers that factors affecting children should be given substantial weight, but the best interests of a child are one of many important factors and do not outweigh everything else. The officer weighs them with all other factors.
What does an officer look at when assessing the best interests of a child?
IRCC lists examples: the child's age, how dependent the child is on the applicant, the child's establishment in Canada, who has legal custody, the child's links to the other country and conditions there, medical or special needs, the impact on education, matters related to gender, and the child's own point of view. The list is not exhaustive.
Do I have to raise the best interests of a child myself?
Yes. IRCC says the onus is on the applicant, and it must be clear from what you submit that you rely on this factor. If the evidence is not enough, the officer may find the child's interests were not shown.
Can a child help me get around the 12-month bar after a refused refugee claim?
It can. The 12-month bar does not apply if you give credible evidence that children under 18 would be directly and adversely affected by your removal from Canada.

